16. Debate: The National Development Framework

Part of the debate – in the Senedd at 7:36 pm on 29 September 2020.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mandy Jones Mandy Jones UKIP 7:36, 29 September 2020

Thank you, Minister, for this statement today. The work involved in the development of this framework is self-evident—[Inaudible.] Sorry, there's something in the background.

The work involved in the development of this framework is self-evident, and I send my congratulations to your staff for bringing this forward in such challenging times. The framework is a wide-ranging and comprehensive document and it makes sense that development and planning cascade from Government to regions and finally to be more locally focused at authority level. I do, though, get a strange sense of déjà vu here: another lengthy consultation, another weighty tome of warm words about future generations, the homes that Wales needs, ecosystems and the climate change emergency. In the mix, as usual, is sustainability, active travel, town centres first, et cetera. All of these phrases are very well worn and appear in some form or other in a lot of Welsh Government consultations. It does, though, make perfect sense to divide the country up into regions and for planning to take place on this basis.

I never saw the point—and still don't—of an international convention centre being built in Newport and now I believe there is another one planned for central Cardiff, with all the travel issues that may entail, when north Wales and possibly Wrexham would greatly benefit from such a venue. And while I applaud many of the sentiments behind this approach, why will this approach work when the local development planning process was not taken up by every local authority in a timely or meaningful manner? And let's look at the local level: despite Labour's manifesto pledge in 2016, to—and I quote—

'seek to create stronger, larger local authorities', you have done no such thing despite consultations and commissions and there is still a 22-way bun fight for the spoils, which rather flies in the face of regionalisation. So, how will that work? 

The document covers several areas, and due to time constraints I'll limit my remarks to just a couple of areas. Housing: it seems to me that the public sector holds many cards in this area. It has land, brownfield sites, defunct buildings—all the more so now that public sector workers are asked to stay at home—and your own staff administer the social housing grant and the public sector in Wales can call upon innovative financial schemes. So, at risk of repeating verbatim my remarks from last week's debate on second homes, why do you need a development framework to give everyone permission to do what they already can do?

Wales is a small and very beautiful country, and while I can see merit in looking at sustainable energy and heating schemes across the country, I'm disappointed once again to see that wind farms remain in the mix. These are quite simply blots on the landscape and the seascape and no one ever seems to factor in the massive decommissioning costs in terms of money and carbon. Plus the fact that you won't get a windfarm in my valley, as we've already seen them off. We have a site in north Wales right for a new, clean nuclear power station and much of the legwork has already been done for tidal power schemes, so what other forms of energy generation did you consider and then discount, and what was the reaction of those living locally to these priority areas?

I see that once again in the Welsh Government document, 'town centre first' features. Will you undertake here and now to make sure that the Welsh public sector starts to really channel this? The Welsh Government's own flagship buildings in north Wales, Merthyr and Aberystwyth fall well short of the mark of being located close enough to town centres to make any sort of real difference to town centres, especially now. And Wales's newest hospital near Cwmbran, while it looks absolutely magnificent, is not particularly easily accessible, especially for visitors, and nowhere near a town centre or district that will benefit from its opening. So, my final question to you, Minister, is: will the public sector in Wales, including the Welsh Government, lead by example here, or will it be another case of do as I say? Thank you.