8. Plaid Cymru Debate: Free school meals eligibility

Part of the debate – in the Senedd at 4:43 pm on 24 February 2021.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Suzy Davies Suzy Davies Conservative 4:43, 24 February 2021

I think I must begin by asking why this is the third time we're debating Plaid's position on free school meals in as many months. This motion replicates an amendment to the budget debate on 9 February, just two weeks ago. Back in December, we agreed that if you had no recourse to public funds then you shouldn't also have to worry about relying on someone's discretion in order for your child to be able to eat, and we recognised also that some families who might not have struggled in normal circumstances to pay for their children's food have found it more difficult during the pandemic, and that we supported Welsh Government's extension of free school lunch provision during the holiday period while we were in the throes of all this. But I also said that we shouldn't slip quietly into perpetuity with what was on offer here, and that we did not agree with proposals on universal provision of free school meals, and, in all fairness, Helen Mary was gracious enough to recognise that this was down to different philosophies about how best to tackle child poverty, rather than an unwillingness to face and take action on the challenge. 

Universal free school meals includes breakfasts, which we reject for the reasons I set out in December, which means we cannot support the Welsh Government amendment, but, having said that, we do agree with paragraph 1 of that amendment, and acknowledge again the Government's COVID response on free school meals, as well as wishing it well with its review. But we will be supporting the motion unamended. Earlier this month, we agreed that any underspent budget this year should be targeted in a temporary way to help families in receipt of universal credit. There are families in receipt of universal credit for the first time because COVID has robbed them of their jobs, and who will remain on universal credit for the foreseeable part of the coming year because they cannot find work or better paid work. But I have to say, Plaid, it was touch and go that we are agreeing to this motion as it is, again, because Welsh Government has kindly drawn our attention to the Education Policy Institute report in its own amendment, and what it says about the four nations' spending decisions on education during the pandemic. One hundred and seventy four pounds being spent on education recovery for every pupil in England, but just £88 per pupil in Wales, despite Wales receiving the £5.2 billion extra from the UK Government that we've heard of. We've had the lowest number of home learning hours here too, especially in more disadvantaged families, although, of course, those families have suffered the most across the UK. And Welsh Government has also been less generous up until now with its support for childcare funding and additional learning needs per pupil. And that should worry all of us who believe that education is an essential part of the route out of poverty, seeing this huge discrepancy in catch-up investment, meaning that too many of tomorrow's parents will still be relying on free school meals however much Welsh Government fiddles about with the criteria. Thank you.