Allegations of abuse on Caldey Island

Part of 3. Topical Questions – in the Senedd at 3:32 pm on 29 November 2017.

Alert me about debates like this

Photo of Mr Simon Thomas Mr Simon Thomas Plaid Cymru 3:32, 29 November 2017

In addition to the questions that have already been raised, I think it is important to underline that Caldey is a place of pilgrimage and sanctuary, which has been in the Christian tradition for over 1,600 years in Wales and people will continue to go there. And the current monks, although they're not directly involved in this scandal, are the inheritors of the tradition there and are therefore the keepers, quite literally the keepers, of the flame, in terms of the standards that need to be upheld on the island.

What concerns me from what I've heard and read in the press, and your reply today, is that even at the time that the original complaint was made, the rules in place then—even then; you've talked about the improvements since, but even then—meant that that complaint should have been referred to the police. It wasn't, and the then abbot—not the current, but the then abbot—in effect covered it up. That is a pattern of behaviour that we've seen wider, not in the Catholic Church only, but in church institutions—in all institutions, let's be honest; it's an institutional thing.

So, although in reply to other Members you've talked about the children's commissioner writing to ascertain that procedures are in place, what I'd like to hear from you today is that the Welsh Government will do that, and, ideally, that you can give assurances here to the Chamber today that you have either seen or have had assurances about the protection procedures for not just children, but vulnerable adults as well, on Caldey Island, and that these procedures are ones that are not only in place, but are actively followed, and that the right training has been put in place to ensure that the situation would be resolved if anything were to happen today. It's not just historic, it's not that the procedures were bad in the past; they weren't even followed. There was a deliberate cover up, and it's not that long ago, and we must be assured that it can't happen again.