Part of 1. Questions to the Minister for Education – in the Senedd at 1:44 pm on 9 January 2019.
Well, we wouldn't disagree with you on that, of course, because a similar academy was in our Welsh Conservatives manifesto, and we would like to see a very successful version of that providing the results that I hope we would all see. My question was: who is actually driving that? Is it going to be civil servants who design it or is it going to be teachers? You heard from me about the concerns on self-evaluation yesterday, and I look forward to hearing a bit more from you as time goes on about how that will look.
But let's look at that curriculum reform that you were talking about. Earlier this week, those same headteachers criticised the pace of change in schools as secondary schools are—again, I'm quoting—
'dealing with reformed GCSEs and A levels at the same time as trying to prepare for the new curriculum', something that was supported in principle by the Welsh Local Government Association, who told the Children, Young People and Education Committee in their written evidence that
'not enough of what actually matters has been included in the AoLEs…too many statements are generic, poorly defined and weak on knowledge and skills development', and this being likely to result in pupils' development being left to chance, and a total of 30 areas of learning and experience will be
'particularly challenging for primary teachers where the load is not shared across departments/faculties.'
And, finally, most damning of all, while the
'landscape is awash with experts getting “excited” about curriculum reform…the reality is that workload-weary teachers will have to try to make it work on the ground.'
Now, you're ring-fencing an awful lot of money to train teachers for this new curriculum—for this—when we're not really clear what 'this' means, and at the same time, that means there is money not going into school budgets, which is not enabling teacher freedom and which is not enabling greater flexibilities for schools. How are you responding to the fears raised by both the headteachers and the WLGA that the curriculum, which is meant to be ready for next year, isn't going to be on time in any clear and meaningful way and what are you going to do about it?